Take a deep breath. It’s going to be ok. I haven’t lost my mind. Nor am I planning on villanizing Chad's mom. Without daughters-in-law and mothers-in-law, we’d have little reason for college subjects like Anthropology and Psychology. There’d be no wise sayings like, “It takes all kinds.” There’d be no ‘Everybody Loves Raymond.’ Right?
So, buckle up – here we go.
I guess I need to start with the oldest story – the best story. The story that started it all. The wedding dress story. Chad and I were engaged and I was over at his Aunt’s house. Sande (my mother-in-law), Chad’s aunt, and I were in one of her bedrooms talking and his aunt asked me about my wedding dress. I hadn’t bought it yet but I had some ideas and Chad’s mom said, “You can borrow Dede’s dress. I still have it.” For those of you who aren’t in the know, Dede is Chad’s ex wife.
I’ll wait while you gasp or laugh or to collect your jaw from the floor.
To say I was stunned doesn’t really cover it. I’m a classic overthinker, so I naturally assumed Sande hated me. She then cheerfully offered Dede’s silk flower bouquet, the serving ware they used at the wedding, and a cookbook signed “Merry Christmas, Dede.”
Years went by and I kept these things and others like burrs under my saddle. Burrs that dug in over time and got so under my skin, they became a part of me. I spent ridiculous amounts of time thinking about them from various angles. I pondered, fretted, overthought every word out of her mouth and never considered that I might be spending too much of my energy being the classic, suspiscious daughter-in-law.
Luckily, we mature – even in our 30’s. I now realize that my mother-in-law is almost comically my complete opposite. And she really makes me look kind of hilarious. Here’s my admittedly VERY BASIC reasoning. I’m Metaphysical Mary and she’s Practical Patty.
Objects to Practical Patty are just that, objects. Practical Patty looks at an item and asks one question, “Is it useful?”
Objects to Metaphysical Mary are not JUST objects. They have energy, memories, associations. Metaphysical Mary asks a multitude of questions. “Does it remind me of a good time or a bad time?” “Is it pretty?” “Is it sentimental?” “Does it match my other belongings?” “Does it have a positive energy?” “Is it out of date?” “Did someone I love give this to me?”
Practical Patty will keep an object for an indefinite amount of time if it is useful. Some Practical Patty’s find that even if a thing isn’t currently useful, it might have a future use, and they keep those things, too.
Metaphysical Mary will throw an item out on an emotional whim and later regret it. She might hold onto a completely useless item for sentimental reasons. She might do anything at all based on her current mood. She is by her very nature, impractical.
Metaphysical Mary and Practical Patty have a very large gap in the way they see things. But, as all things that are related to WHO WE ARE, there isn’t a wrong or a right. There’s my way and your way and the gray matter in between. The negotiable space.
I admit, as Metaphysical Mary, there’s little room for negotiation. I’ve had to grow a lot in terms of understanding the wedding dress was not an intentional insult to me. It had a future use. It was an item of large monetary value that had been worn once and was still in good shape. She later gave it to someone who needed it and was very appreciative. I’m humbled by that.
So, to my mother-in-law (if she still reads my blog), I’m sorry it took me so long to make sense of your offer (and all the offers after that I didn’t understand).
To all Metaphysical Mary’s – chill out. Really. Stop overthinking. Maybe people aren’t as passive-aggressive as you think. Maybe they are just practical.
To all Practical Patty’s – maybe a little effort in understanding the Metaphysical Mary in your life… they don’t make a lot of sense, but if they are in your life, they are worth the effort.
It really does take all kinds.